Monday, May 23, 2011

You Should Be Ashamed

The idea of vicarious redemption is a disgusting one.

The Beginning...

A criminal dons his dapperest suit in preparation for the trial. His bow-tie must be parallel to the floor. His shirt must show three quarters of an inch at each wrist. The rest of his life hangs in the balance. The judge sits. The crowd sits. The lawyers debate. The jury discusses. The jury judges, "Guilty on all charges!." The man's life is at an end in his mind. His last hope destroyed. But, "Wait!" the judge shouts. "I have a sentence to decree." The room falls still in anticipation. "I will have my son tortured to death, to stand in your place. Your judgement is satisfied." says the judge.

The criminal's mind races. Never would he have thought of such a saving grace, and yet... it feels hollow. He had been feeling that he was to get what he deserved, but now... he was to be responsible for the suffering of yet another? Would those he harmed feel satisfied at the shift in justice? Surely not, he thought. Surely the judge was rich enough to pay his debts, but this? Even he, a murderer and a thief, had never even dreamed of torturing someone. The criminal in a final attempt at redemption speaks up to yell, "No! I admit it, I did the crime, punish me. But leave your son alone." The judge stares uncaringly back and says, "No. I will have my son tortured to death and it will be your fault." Blinded by the thought of this added injustice he fights his bonds with all his might until he breaks free. He fights to warn the judges son, to prevent this injustice from being done. This, he thinks, would be the last important thing in his life. So he fights so hard and so tirelessly, that in the chaotic and many-manned attempt to subdue him, the would-be peace-keepers accidentally kill him.

...The End

Anyone should be ashamed to think that the judge is the hero of this story. Even more so if they think that the judge in this story is the greatest example of justice and mercy one could imagine. One may pay my debts. One may even lie in order to do my time in prison, but no one can take away my responsibility for wrong action. The act of scapegoating is central to Christianity, and it demonstrates quite clearly that the belief system is, at it's core, morally bankrupt.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Consistency is Key

"There's a homeless man in our attic!"

"What?"

"It's true! He's been thumping around up there all morning!"

"All morning? How'd he get in there? Didn't we lock up last night?"

"I don't know but he's probably going through all our stuff looking for valuables."

"I'm sure we locked up, did you see him?"

"No, I just heard him."

"Well, how do you know it's a him then?"

"Okay okay, a homeless person. But it's probably a him, just statistically speaking."

"Well, if you only heard the noise, how can you be sure it's a homeless person and not a raccoon or something?"

"I KNOW it's a person. A raccoon couldn't possibly make that much noise."

"Now wait a second, how can you say that you KNOW it's a person when you said yourself that you didn't see anyone?"

"I KNOW it's a person. I'm 100% sure of it. My instincts are spot on on this type of thing."

"Hold on a sec..."

"It's a hairy homeless man who wants soup. He's probably a war vet and wants to find his old war medals which he drunkenly believes reside in our attic. He got in by taking a crowbar to the back door. We should call the cops because he's armed and dangerous and wanted in three counties."

"..."

"What?"

"You can't possibly know all that if the only evidence you have is that you heard something. I didn't hear anything. For all I know you didn't either."

"Just because the truth is frightening doesn't make it not the truth. Don't worry, we'll call the cops. We can hide in the bedroom and lock the door and turn the lights off and I'll cuddle you under the covers to keep you safe. We should probably take our clothes off too because the soup-craving veteran criminal is said to be afraid of naked bodies."

"...in that case, I'll take my chances with the homeless man."



At what point do we stop taking the claims of this person seriously? And for what reasons? Are those reasons consistent with the way we handle claims made by everyone?

Examine your reaction to the dialogue. Were you skeptical right away? Or did it take the claimant making a statement of knowledge that was not apparently available to him?

I don't ask that people convert. I just ask that they be consistent. If it is not okay to accept this persons claims on faith, then why would it be okay to accept the claims of a priest, pastor, rabbi or mullah on faith? Each make claims about reality, with 100% certitude, to which they can not apparently know the answer.







Wednesday, July 28, 2010

The Switcheroo


"The easy confidence with which I know another man's religion is folly teaches me to suspect that my own is also."

Mark Twain
Most people of faith either lack a mechanism for validating and invalidating claims, or they simply suppress that mechanism in favor of a certain belief, a process known as compartmentalization. The compartmentalized belief is impervious to any statement that could be made, any evidence that could be shown, and any proof that could be given which in any way might damage that belief. Therefore, as an attempt to work from the inside out, I present the following:
The Switcheroo
A long time ago God created the universe. He did it in such a way that a very specific process would play out. This process would lead to a beautiful cosmos to look at, and an amazing diversity of life which would yield one of God's eventual favorite species, the human. These carbon-based bipedal primates would have a capacity for intelligence unmatched by their contemporaries (on the same planet at least), and would therefore have a remarkable capacity for good, for evil, for love, for hate, for learning, and for credulity. A rival god named Lucifer swung by once to see what God had created and he coveted it. He was jealous beyond belief at the beauty of this universe and of the creatures that would be in it. So he devised a plan to steal it. Sharing the space was easy enough because both gods are omnipresent.
But that wasn't enough. He wanted the humans. He wanted their minds. The creator god, interestingly enough, didn't care to have the minds of the humans, he just wanted them to use them. Knowing this, Lucifer decided to interfere in human affairs in just such a way, that the humans would create a book which was two-fold in purpose. First, to cripple the minds of the humans and second, to get them to worship him. Lucifer figured this was enough to get the creator god to be jealous of him, purchasing Lucifer the eternal bragging rights which would, in his mind, assuage his insatiable jealousy.
But it didn't work. The creator god had a strong intuition that the humans might overcome the deception. He had read the book that had been written about Lucifer and wagered that the humans would be able to see through the attempt at deception and once again be the creatures they evolved to be. He even noted that some of Lucifer's outrageous jealousy had spilled over into the verses. (There were even some that commanded the humans not to have any other gods before him.) He wasn't going to give Lucifer the satisfaction of caring that billions of humans were going to be worshipping him. So he just folded his arms and observed. He didn't try to stop Lucifer, because he knew it was what Lucifer wanted.
As the millennia passed, it played out exactly as Lucifer wanted. He even had it put in the book that the creator god was not actually the creator god, but the devil, subservient to him in every way. He had set it up such that once the belief took hold, it was virtually impossible for the humans to change their minds.
Will the humans ever emancipate themselves from Lucifer's deception? Will the creator god end up intervening to save the minds of billions? Will any believer be able to freely contemplate this story?
For the conclusion of this dramatic tale... stay tuned.
Here's the question: How can a religious person know that this story isn't absolutely, 100% true, without doubting their own beliefs on the same bases?




Thursday, July 22, 2010

Why I Ridicule People's Faith

"I find your evangelism to be a bit abrasive. Why pursue your former kinsman with derision? What is the point?"

-John Clawson (in response to my facebook ridicules of the beliefs of christianity)

"But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."
-Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia, 1782
"Ridicule is the only weapon which can be used against unintelligible propositions. Ideas must be distinct before reason can act upon them; and no man ever had a distinct idea of the trinity. It is the mere Abracadabra of the mountebanks calling themselves the priests of Jesus."
-Thomas Jefferson, letter to Francis Adrian Van der Kemp, 30 July, 1816

Every time someone says, "Praise god I got the job, He's so great!", "Pray for me that god would see me through this difficult time," or even, "god bless you," or, "I feel blessed," that person, whether they mean to or not, is making a truth claim about the nature of the universe. Much like the participants in the feminist movement would react strongly to even the slightest implication that women were unequal to men (i.e. "one man, one vote," the word "man" to indicate human, and even the exclusion of the female pronoun from texts and speech), a process that helped raise awareness about equal rights, I react strongly to even the slightest implication that there is a god. This is not because I'm dogmatically against the prospect, but because I require people to be able to articulate what it is they believe and why in the public marketplace of ideas, and because I'm deeply interested in what's true. If they're claiming that there is a god then I want to know why they believe that. Because, if their beliefs are more in line with what's true than mine are, then I covet their knowledge. But, if they're spouting corrosive untruths, I take it upon myself to defend the knowledge which has allowed our human civilization to survive the cold and unfeeling world around us thus far, the knowledge that is our best hope for progress and survival through the ages.

When someone even says something as innocuous as, "I feel blessed," the implication is that there's a magic being upstairs blessing and cursing people as it sees fit. All one has to do is open their eyes to the needless suffering that takes place on our imperfect sphere to see the repugnance of this idea, even more so the idea that such a being should be worshipped.

The forum in which I ridicule the faithful is typically facebook but is always a public forum for a few reasons. When I first started becoming outspoken about my atheism, I'd do it in private at the expense of my close friends. This caused some hard feelings and a lot of drama. When I gave it a little more thought it became apparent to me that I was being no better than those faith-heads who show up to your door and ask if you have a few minutes. I was imposing my beliefs and thought processes on them and I had no right. The reason that a public forum cannot constitute an imposition is because anyone is free to ignore what I say without appearing rude. Facebook is particularly good about this because the status updates on which I frequently comment have a mechanism that makes it easy to exclude me from being able to comment or even see them. If someone doesn't like what I have to say, it is just too easy for them to ignore me for me to be imposing anything upon them.

Relatively unchallenged beliefs are corrupting our society. The belief that because someone is homosexual that they should have less rights than "normal" people, the attempts to teach non-science in science classes, the major impediments to scientific research that could save the lives and better the quality of life of countless people, and the attempts of religion to control our secular government should be combatted with passion and reason. I look forward to a day when science, education, and human rights can charge forward unimpeded by iron-age superstition. So much so that I fight for it.